← All insights
·10 min read·By Christopher Sanovei

What a Lead Should Actually Cost Your Service Business

Cost per lead is the wrong number to optimise. Here is the arithmetic that tells you whether your marketing is working, and how to run it on the back of an envelope.

Most marketing reports lead with cost per lead. It is the wrong headline, and optimising for it quietly makes businesses poorer.

Cheap leads are easy and often worthless

Any agency can halve your cost per lead. Widen the targeting, loosen the keywords, run a form with two fields, and watch the number fall. You will get more leads for less money. You will also get tyre kickers, wrong service areas, and people shopping five quotes.

The number that decides whether your marketing works is cost per acquired customer, and the only way to get it is to track which inquiries actually turned into paid jobs.

The arithmetic

You need four numbers, and you probably know three of them already.

  • Total marketing spend for the month, including the agency fee. Not just ad spend. The fee is part of the cost of getting a customer.
  • Inquiries: calls, form fills and messages, minus spam and existing customers calling about an old job.
  • Jobs won from those inquiries.
  • Average profit per job, not revenue. Profit is what pays for marketing.

Then: spend divided by jobs won gives you cost per customer. Compare that against average profit per job. If a customer costs you $400 and nets you $900, you should be spending more, not less. If a customer costs $900 and nets $400, no amount of clever creative fixes that.

The number almost nobody tracks

Average profit per job is where most owners guess. They know revenue per job and they know roughly what their margins are, but the two have never been put side by side specifically for this decision.

It is worth an hour with your last fifty invoices. Once you know it, every marketing question gets easier, because you have a threshold. A customer is worth acquiring up to the point where the cost approaches the profit, and you can decide your own comfort margin below that.

Lifetime value, handled honestly

Service businesses have a real advantage here: a maintenance customer is not one job. A first time repair that becomes an annual service plan is worth multiples of the first invoice. That genuinely changes what you can afford to pay to acquire one.

But be careful. Lifetime value is the number agencies reach for when the immediate numbers look bad. If someone is justifying your spend using projected five year value, ask what the first job alone returned. Both numbers should be on the table.

Why this is hard to actually do

The arithmetic is simple. Getting the inputs is not, for one reason: most inquiries come by phone, and phone calls do not come with a source attached.

A form fill carries its own history. You can see the ad, the search, the landing page. A call does not, unless you have set up tracking numbers or your team asks every caller where they found you, which they will do for about two weeks.

This is why so many service businesses genuinely cannot tell you what works. It is not laziness. The majority of their inquiries arrive through the one channel nobody instrumented.

The fix

Three things, in order of effort. Mark every inquiry won or lost, with the job value, within a week of it closing. Put a tracking number on each major channel so calls carry a source. And measure by the month the lead arrived, not the month the job closed, so the spend that created a customer gets credited with it.

Do the first one even if you do nothing else. An owner who knows how many of last month's inquiries became customers is already ahead of most of their competitors, and ahead of most of the agencies reporting to them.

A note on profit versus invoice value

Earlier we said to compare cost per customer against profit per job, and that is the right comparison to make in your own head. It is also a number nobody outside your business can see. Materials, labour, overhead and the way you allocate them are yours, and any agency printing a profit figure on your report is printing a guess with your name on it.

So the honest way to report is in invoice value: what the won jobs were worth as billed. That is a number you can check against your own books, and you can apply your own margin to it privately. If an agency tells you a month returned four dollars of booked work for every dollar spent, you know what that means for your business better than they do. If they tell you it returned three dollars of profit, ask how they would know.

Why the month the lead arrived is the month that counts

A customer who called in March and booked in May belongs to March. The spend that produced the call was March's spend; the May invoice is its result. Count it in May and March looks like a bad month and May looks like a free one, and you will make decisions on both that are wrong.

This is called cohort attribution, and it has one awkward consequence: a month is not finished when it ends. Inquiries keep converting for weeks afterwards, so the customer count for last month is a floor that rises as the undecided ones resolve. A dashboard that shows last month's number going up over time is not broken; it is telling the truth. One that shows a final number on the first of the month is guessing.

Counting the calls without changing your number

Tracking numbers are the traditional fix for the phone problem, and they come with a cost most owners underestimate: you end up with a different number on your website than on your truck, your profile and every directory. That inconsistency is itself a ranking problem, and the numbers have to be kept forever or the directories go stale.

There is a quieter way. On a phone, nearly every call to a business starts with a tap on the number. That tap can be counted, with the page and the source attached, without changing the number at all. It undercounts, because someone who reads the number and dials it by hand is invisible, so the figure is a floor rather than a total. But a floor you can trust beats a total you cannot, and it leaves your business number alone.

What good looks like

Put the four numbers on one page every month: what you spent in total, how many people got in touch, how many became customers, and what each one cost. Put the search-only version beside it, with your retainer alone divided across the customers search brought, so you can see what that work earned on its own. Then put the invoice value of the jobs next to all of it.

If the numbers are good, you will know why. If they are bad, you will know where. Either way you are no longer paying for marketing nobody can explain, which is the only position from which the spend can be made to work.

Christopher Sanovei

Founder, Orvelo Solutions

Chris runs Orvelo Solutions from Orlando, Florida, working with home and local service businesses on local search, Google Business Profiles and the arithmetic of what a customer costs.

Want to know where you actually rank?

We will run your business across your real service area and show you where you sit against your competitors. Free, and no pitch.

Book a free visibility audit